Skip to content

News

Dispute of the month: circle.eu, a trademark that came 20 years late

A Danish company holding the EU trademark CIRCLE lost its .eu complaint for circle.eu on 7 October 2026, though the holder never answered. The domain dated from 2006, nearly 20 years before the trademarks, circle is a common word, and refusing to sell was not bad faith.

A Danish company that held the EU trademark CIRCLE asked for the transfer of circle.eu and lost, even though the holder of the name never answered the complaint. The decision in case CAC-ADREU-008973, dated 7 October 2026 and published by the Czech Arbitration Court on 11 October, shows the limit of a dispute procedure when the domain is older than the trademark.

What were the facts?

The domain name circle.eu was registered on 15 November 2006 by a private individual in Denmark. The complainant, also based in Denmark, held two EU trademarks for CIRCLE, a word mark and a logo, both filed on 14 June 2023 and registered on 30 January and 4 February 2026, for goods and services in classes 9, 42 and 45.

The complainant asked for the transfer of the name. It argued that the domain was identical to its trademark and that it would be an important step towards the wider European market, and said the holder had refused to transfer it. The holder filed no response.

What did the panel decide?

It rejected the complaint. Under the .eu rules, a complainant must show that the domain name is identical or confusingly similar to a protected name, and either that the holder has no right or legitimate interest in it, or that it was registered or used in bad faith. The panel found the first condition met, since circle.eu is identical to CIRCLE, but neither of the other two.

ConditionPanel’s finding
Identical or confusingly similar to a protected rightmet: the name is identical to the CIRCLE trademark
No right or legitimate interest of the holdernot shown
Registration or use in bad faithnot shown

Why did the complainant lose?

Three reasons appear in the decision. First, the trademarks came almost twenty years after the domain, and the complainant showed no earlier right, nor that the holder knew of it in 2006. Second, circle is an ordinary English word, which leaves room for a legitimate interest in holding the name. Third, a refusal to transfer the name after being contacted is not, on its own, bad faith: the panel noted that the holder had not, for example, offered the name for sale at an unreasonable price.

The panel added that a registration before the trademark does not exclude bad faith in every case, for example if the holder targeted an existing business. No such circumstance was shown here. Its summary also notes that the complainant’s plan to expand in Europe concerned its own present interest, not the holder’s intention at the time of registration.

What is the lesson for brand owners?

A dispute procedure recovers names taken against your rights. It does not buy names registered in good faith before your brand existed, even when the holder stays silent. Before you file, check three dates: when the domain was registered, when your rights began, and when you first used the brand. If the domain is older and the word is common, a negotiated purchase is often the realistic route.

What should you do now?

  1. Register the domain names of a new brand at the same time as the trademark application, in the extensions that matter to you.
  2. Before a complaint, compare the registration date of the domain with the date of your earliest right.
  3. Keep evidence of any approach by the holder, such as an offer to sell at a high price: it can show bad faith.
  4. For an older name on a common word, consider a negotiated acquisition rather than a complaint. For a .eu case that does qualify, EURid’s reduced fee of €700 applies until the end of 2026.

Domgate is a corporate ccTLD registrar for 1,300+ extensions. It helps brand owners recover names through defensive actions where their rights allow it, and buy them through domain acquisition where they do not.

Contact Domgate

Explore your opportunities Let's get in touch!

Our team answers within 24 hours on working days.

Your reseller project
How would you like to connect? You can choose more than one.
Which services interest you? You can choose more than one.

Your details are used to answer you, nothing else. How we use your data · Privacy Policy

How we use your data
Your personal data: Domgate uses the details you give in this form to answer your message. Legal basis: our legitimate interest in answering you, or steps taken at your request before a contract (GDPR, Art. 6(1)(f) and (b)). They are read by the Domgate team. If you give your telephone number about sales, local presence, brand protection or our reseller programme, our team may also call you back to present our services; you may object to this at any time. To check that the form is not sent by a robot, Cloudflare (Turnstile) receives technical data from your browser, such as your IP address. We delete the entries of this form 36 months after we receive them. You may ask to access, correct or erase them, to receive them in a portable format, to restrict their use or to object to it, by writing to our data protection officer, Philippe Boos, at [email protected], and you may complain to the CNIL (cnil.fr). More in our privacy policy.